Skip to main content
Cheat Day Diet
woman eating french fries and holding a container of french fries
Jan 31

Cheat Day Diet

Cheat Day Diet

cheat day diet -woman eating french fries and holding a container of french fries

 

When I was in the middle of a year-long plateau (yeah, I didn’t lose weight for a year), I tried everything to break through. I exercised more, I ate less, I went to the doctor because I knew it had to be my thyroid (it wasn’t). At one point I came across a book that promoted cheat days. I’d love to talk about my experience with them.

 

I gleefully read the book thinking I was going to eat anything and everything I wanted and still lose weight. That’s what the book told me, so I believed it. It talked about giving yourself a break from the monotony of dieting and resetting your metabolism. It made sense.

 

I hadn’t reached the point in my weight loss journey where I began to understand that I wasn’t dieting, I was changing my habits forever. I still believed that “cheating” was bad and this book was going to show me how I could be “bad” and still lose weight.

 

Now I know how to be “bad”. I used to binge on Pop-Tarts and Pepsi. I could go through nearly a box of Pop-Tarts and a 2 liter of soda a day while I mindlessly watched television. The thought of being “bad” again scared me, yet I wanted to eat without restraint.

 

So, I gave a “cheat day diet” a try. I ate healthy for 6 days of the week and on the 7th – lookout! I don’t remember what all I ate, since it has been several years ago, however I can assure you there was chocolate, flour, sugar, salt, and fat involved. I loved every minute of it. I was so happy and glad to be on the “cheat day diet”.

 

Until I stepped on the scale.

 

Somehow eating everything and anything on my cheat day did not help me to lose weight. I couldn’t believe it. I had followed the diet to the letter and I had gained weight. One month of my weight loss journey down the drain!

 

But it wasn’t down the drain, it was a learning experience for me. It taught me that I need to budget my calories. I can “cheat”, if that’s what you want to call it. I can have cake, I just need to put it into my calorie budget. I can have it everyday if I want and budget for it, but since I have other goals like lowering my body fat and keeping my heart healthy, I don’t have it everyday. When I do have it, I don’t feel like I’m cheating, I am just living normally.

cheat day diet - little boy shoving popcorn in his mouth while holding a container of popcorn

The “cheat day diet” showed me that I can “diet” and restrict calories for 6 days and have a calorie deficit of 500 to 1,000 calories a day (3,000 – 6,000 calories total), but on “cheat day”, I can eat that and more.

 

Sonic french toast sticks + syrup + large OJ = 820 calories

Big Mac Meal = 1350 calories

I’m going to have a chocolate chip cookie from McD’s if I’m eating there. 160 calories each and I probably ate 1 1/2 (had to share with hubby)

Cookies = 240 calories

Seafood and Crab sub = 820 + 330 calories for mayo = 1150 calories

Candy bar – king size I’m sure – 440 calories

Total = 4,000

 

That’s not including any beverage except OJ. The one thing I swore off completely because of my raging addiction was soda – of any kind – diet, regular or natural. However, I was probably drinking sweet tea at the time, so you can safely add several hundred more calories to that total.

 

That’s why a “cheat day diet” doesn’t work for me. If I was restricting my self for 6 days and had a 3,000 calorie deficit, well, I completely erased it on day 7 with a fast food frenzy. Even if I had refrained from cookies and a candy bar, it still would have eradicated my deficit and the week of “dieting” was null.

 

Some people think a “cheat meal” is the way to go. For me, it isn’t. If I think in black and white terms, “cheating” or “being good”, then I start playing those dieting mind games again. I refuse.

 

I am eating healthy for the rest of my life – God willing. Healthy to me means, moderation. I will eat cake in moderation. I will eat cookies and candy – in moderation. I will not beat myself up. I will budget for it, just like I budget for a great new purse.

 

So, cheat days don’t work for me, but I know they work for some. I would love to hear from you. What do you think about cheat days? Do you use them?

 

Like what you read? Read more about my 125lb weight loss

 

 

Related Posts

No Bake Icebox Cake

No Bake Icebox Cake I'm embarrassed to say I  just now discovered icebox cakes.  How...

the perfect pumpkin muffin

Intentionally Eating Through the Holidays

Intentionally Eating Through the Holidays Change is scary.  You know the routine and the thought...

Salad In A Jar

If you haven't tried Salad In A Jar, you are missing out! These salads stay...

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Small Bites, Big Results book out now! Buy Now
Hello. Add your message here.